Basics

Settlement mediation: how it works and how to prepare the numbers

Settlement mediation is a negotiation run by a neutral mediator. Here is how the day works, what is binding, and the money questions to settle first.

Ioannis Kyprianou, ACCA-qualified accountant•November 16, 2026•9 min read
Settlement mediation: how it works and how to prepare the numbers

Settlement mediation is a structured negotiation in which a neutral third party, the mediator, helps the two sides of a legal claim try to reach an agreement. The mediator does not decide who is right and cannot force a result. If both sides agree on terms and sign them, the case settles; if they do not, the claim carries on towards trial as if the mediation had not happened.

Most writing on mediation covers tactics. This guide looks at the part that determines what you actually keep: the fees, costs and liens that come out of a settlement figure, the tax wording, and the decision between a lump sum and periodic payments, all of which are easier to deal with before or during the mediation than afterwards. It is general education, not legal or tax advice. Procedures and confidentiality rules vary by state and court, so rely on your own attorney for your case.

What mediation is, and how it differs from arbitration and trial

People often confuse mediation with arbitration. They are very different.

Mediation Arbitration Trial
Who decides the outcome? The parties, by agreement The arbitrator Judge or jury
Is the neutral's view binding? No Usually yes Yes, subject to appeal
Can you walk away? Yes Generally not once it has begun No
Formality Informal, private Hearing with evidence Formal, public
Result if successful Signed settlement agreement Award Judgment

In mediation you keep control. Nothing happens unless you agree to it.

When mediation happens and who attends

Mediation can be voluntary, with both sides simply agreeing to try it, or ordered by the court. Many courts require the parties to mediate, or to attempt some form of alternative dispute resolution, before a civil case is given a trial date. It commonly takes place after enough evidence has been exchanged for each side to assess the claim, though it can happen earlier, sometimes before a lawsuit is filed.

Those present usually include:

  • You and your attorney.
  • The defence attorney and an insurance representative. In an injury case the money normally comes from an insurer, and courts and mediators generally expect someone with authority to settle to attend or be reachable.
  • The mediator. Often a retired judge or an experienced attorney, chosen jointly by the parties or appointed by the court.
  • Sometimes a settlement consultant. Where periodic payments are a possibility, a structured settlement broker may attend or be on call to price payment options.

How a mediation day usually runs

Formats differ, but a typical session follows this pattern.

  1. Written submissions. Before the day, each side sends the mediator a short confidential statement of its position, often building on the earlier settlement demand letter.
  2. Opening. The mediator explains the ground rules. Some mediations include a joint session with brief opening remarks; many now go straight to separate rooms.
  3. Private caucuses. The mediator moves between the rooms, carrying offers and counter-offers and testing each side's assumptions. What you tell the mediator privately is normally kept from the other side unless you authorise it to be shared.
  4. Narrowing the gap. Offers often move slowly at first. Mediators use devices such as brackets ("we will come down to X if they come up to Y") or, late in the day, a mediator's proposal that each side accepts or rejects privately.
  5. Agreement or impasse. If terms are agreed, they are written down and signed before anyone leaves. If not, the mediator may follow up by phone in the following days, and many cases that do not settle on the day settle later.

A session can take a few hours or a full day. Complex or multi-party cases can need more than one.

Is what you say in mediation confidential?

Broadly yes, but the protection comes from several sources and has limits.

  • Rules on compromise negotiations. In federal court, Federal Rule of Evidence 408 generally prevents settlement offers and statements made in compromise negotiations from being used to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim. States have comparable rules. The rule has exceptions, since the same evidence can sometimes be admitted for other purposes.
  • Mediation privilege. Many states have statutes that specifically protect mediation communications. A number of jurisdictions have adopted the Uniform Mediation Act, which creates a privilege against disclosure with listed exceptions; others have their own statutes, and the scope differs considerably from state to state.
  • The mediation agreement. Parties usually sign a confidentiality agreement at the start.

Confidentiality does not make facts disappear. Information the other side could obtain through ordinary evidence-gathering does not become protected because it was mentioned in mediation. Your attorney will know what your state's rules cover.

What mediation costs and who pays

Private mediators usually charge by the hour or by the day, and the fee is commonly split between the sides, though the parties can agree something else. Some court-connected programmes provide mediators at reduced or no cost.

Your share is normally treated as a case cost. Under a typical contingency fee agreement the attorney advances costs and recovers them from the settlement. Whether costs are deducted before or after the attorney's percentage is calculated changes your net figure, so check the wording.

Work out your net figure before the day

Offers at mediation are quoted gross. What you take home is the gross figure minus attorney fees, case costs and any liens that must be repaid. Going in without that calculation makes it hard to judge an offer in the room.

The figures below are purely illustrative, based on assumed fee and lien amounts.

Item Illustrative amount
Gross settlement offer $300,000
Attorney fee (assumed one-third) −$100,000
Case costs, including mediator's fee share −$12,000
Health plan and medical liens (after negotiation) −$38,000
Net to claimant $150,000

In this example every extra $30,000 on the gross adds about $20,000 to the net, because the fee is a percentage while costs and liens are fixed. These numbers are assumptions for illustration only; your fee percentage, costs and liens will differ, so confirm them with your attorney before acting.

Three preparation steps make the table usable:

  • Get current lien figures. Medicare, Medicaid, health plans and medical providers may have repayment rights. Asking for payoff or conditional payment figures in advance, and knowing which are negotiable, avoids agreeing a number that later shrinks. See medical liens on a settlement.
  • Know your costs to date. Ask your attorney for a running total, including expert fees.
  • Decide your walk-away net, not gross. Then translate it back into the gross figure needed to produce it.

Tax and payment terms to raise before you sign

Several points are far easier to deal with in the room than after the agreement is signed.

Allocation and tax wording. Under IRC §104(a)(2), damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness are generally excluded from gross income. Punitive damages and interest are taxable, and damages for emotional distress not attributable to a physical injury are generally taxable too. Where a claim has mixed components, how the agreement describes and allocates the payment matters, and the IRS looks at what the payment was intended to replace. Raise the wording during the mediation so it reflects the real basis of the claim.

Lump sum or periodic payments. If you might want some of the money paid over time, it has to be part of the settlement terms. Once you have an unrestricted right to the cash, you cannot later convert it into a tax-free structured settlement. In practice that means the term sheet signed at mediation should either set out the periodic payments or expressly preserve your right to elect them, with the defendant or insurer agreeing to fund them through a qualified assignment. Once a structure is in place, selling the payments later requires court approval under state Structured Settlement Protection Acts, and IRC §5891 imposes an excise tax on purchasers who skip that step. The trade-offs are set out in structured settlement vs lump sum.

Public benefits. If you receive means-tested benefits such as SSI or Medicaid, a settlement paid to you directly can affect eligibility. Whether a special needs trust or other arrangement is needed should be settled before the money is paid.

Medicare's future interest. In some cases, particularly workers' compensation, the parties consider setting funds aside for future injury-related care that Medicare would otherwise cover.

Timing of payment. Ask for a payment deadline in the agreement, and what happens if it is missed.

The agreement signed at the end

A successful mediation normally ends with a short written document, sometimes called a term sheet or memorandum of settlement, signed by the parties and their attorneys. A more detailed release follows later.

Treat the short document as the deal. In most jurisdictions a signed mediation agreement containing the essential terms is an enforceable contract, even though a fuller release is still to come. Changing your mind the next morning is generally not an option. Before signing, check that it covers:

  • the amount, who pays it and by when;
  • whether the figure includes or excludes liens, costs and fees;
  • the tax allocation or description of the damages;
  • any periodic payment terms, or the right to elect them;
  • the scope of the release, plus any confidentiality or non-disparagement terms;
  • any conditions, such as court approval.

Court approval is typically required where the claimant is a minor or lacks legal capacity, and in some other categories of case. The settlement is not final until it is given.

If mediation does not produce a settlement

An impasse is not a failure of the case. Both sides leave knowing more about the other's position and the remaining gap. Negotiation often continues by phone, a second session can be arranged, or the case proceeds to trial. What was said in mediation generally stays protected under the rules described above.

Frequently asked questions

Is a mediated settlement legally binding?

The mediation process itself is not binding, and nobody can impose a result on you. A settlement agreement that you sign at the end generally is binding and enforceable as a contract, subject to any required court approval.

How long does settlement mediation take?

Many sessions last half a day to a full day. Straightforward claims can resolve in a few hours, while complex or multi-party disputes may take more than one session.

Who pays for the mediator?

The fee is usually split between the sides unless they agree otherwise. Your share is typically advanced by your attorney as a case cost and deducted from the settlement under your fee agreement.

Do I have to accept an offer made at mediation?

No. The decision to settle is yours. Your attorney advises and the mediator may give a view, but you can decline and continue with the claim.


This guide is for general educational purposes only and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Rates and rules change; verify current figures before acting. Consult a licensed professional about your situation.